Exclusive amateur content.

These are all original amateur scenes featuring the lovely Mandy Blake. She brings some very sexy models to her room for some hot lesbian play. They use toys on each other, going down on each other, and make out. You can tell Mandy loves the ladies and they have a great time in her experienced hands.

This is a pretty good-sized site, with 124 scenes currently online.

Videos can be streamed in browser using Flash and downloaded as wmvs and mp4s. Both are offered as full length scenes and clips and the wmvs come in two quality settings.

Members of Her First Fat Girl also get access to Mandy's Playhouse for even more chubby girl action.

Room for quality upgrades.

Though I thought the videos looked fine, overall quality could be improved. They generally play at around 2000K and 720 x 480. They look amateur, which is fine, they could just be a touch sharper.

Erratic updates.

On average, Mandy adds two new scenes per month. However, it's been a month at this point with nothing added. It's probably just a bit of summer slow down, but even twice a week is pretty infrequent.

Needs more browse tools.

Navigation could be expanded. The scenes are listed in the order they were added and that's it. There are no other sort options, no list of girls Mandy has hooked up with, nothing.

There are no actual photos here, just vidcaps.

The older scenes don't include a Flash option.

Hot exclusive niche action, but otherwise things are pretty basic.

Her First Fat Girl is a fun niche site. I enjoyed the material but there's work to be done. More consistent updates would be a good start, along with more advanced navigation and a quality upgrade. Membership is $30 a month, which is ok since you get bonus site access, but otherwise it would be a stretch. All in all, it's a mixed bag. I liked the concept but the site is best considered as an add on to her main site.