Adult Site Reviews

Advanced Search

Top Gay Sites

1. William Higgins 89.5
2. Blake Mason 89.0
3. Pride Studios 88.0
4. 87.5
5. Active Duty 87.5
6. Randy Blue 87.5
7. Sean Cody 87.0
8. Next Door Studi... 87.0
9. Gay Room 87.0
10. English Lads 87.0
11. BF Collection 87.0
12. Staxus 86.0
13. Str8 Hell 86.0
14. Broke Straight ... 85.5
15. College Dudes 85.5

View All : Gay Sites
Related Niches

1. Hardcore - 2271 Sites
2. Anal - 177 Sites
3. Fisting - 21 Sites
4. For Women - 17 Sites

View All : Niches

Athletic Model Guild

Pay Site

Athletic Model Guild celebrates the classic male physique, and offers pics, videos and other content of the Guild which has been in existence since 1945.

Primary Niche: Gay Porn

TBP Notice This is a special notice regarding this site.

Special Notice!

We have reserved our right not to do business with this company at this time. Therefore we are no longer linking or reviewing its web-sites, including this one. We have left this page up for users who still wish to post their own reviews or comments.

TBP & PU Staff

Site Facts All the glorious stats and details about

Cost & Billing

Monthly: $24.95 (recurs at $19.95/mo.)
Monthly: $34.95 (non-recurring)
Multi-Mo: $59.95 (3 months, recurs $19.95/mo.)
CC Processor: No Independent Merchant
Notes: Cost is for Classics content. Users can join separately; cost options are separate and can be found there.


Exclusivity: All content is exclusive (owner verifies content is all exclusive, though some of their content is availalbe by DVD as well.).
Download Limit: No information found in the terms and conditions.
Models: 1000+ Models
Other: blog, store

Site Launched: Jan 2004
Facts Updated: 12-20-10
Listed Date: Feb '06

Content Updates

Update Log: No
Content Dated: No
Last Content Update:
12-20-10 (as of 12-20-10)
Details: Dates only on most recent content. Looks like multiple weekly video updates with an occational gallery update.

Company Info

AthleticModelGuild Co.
0 Sites Listed

To understand all the info above, check out our Site Facts Glossary.

Review Our most detailed review format ever!

pretty good

Pic Count:
Pic Quality:
Vid Count:
Vid Quality:

Grades have no direct impact on the overall score.

Grade Criteria

Review Log

  Visit Site
Athletic Model Guild Review by Spencer Athletic Model Guild

Review by Spencer

Released Apr 6, '10 , Written Mar 31, '10

Athletic Model Guild is up for review today, and it's a pretty unique and interesting site overall, mostly because of how different it is. The bodybuilder/muscular niche is a nice departure from the norm, but they go even beyond that. A lot of the stuff you'll see here seems to be older material, which is why you're signing up for the "classic" section of their site on this one. They have shot all their own material for decades, and put a lot of it into a line of DVDs they offer. There are dudes in pretty weird undies doing some funky wrestling moves from back in the 60's. There's also the required nudes, but their gay DVD archive is where most of the content is at. It's an odd collection and assortment in the end, but maybe it's up your alley. Fans of theirs should already be members here in my opinion, so I'm mostly looking at the site as a new users of theirs. $25 gets you in for the first month, but that drops to $20 a month after that.

The Pros

  Pretty unique muscular niche.

Not only do they delve into the bodybuilding and muscular niche here, they take it a step further. A lot of this material seems pretty old, so you're getting a glimpse of these hot, built guys back when they were a little more pure in their fitness.

  Lots of content overall.

Once you add in the pretty large collection of hardcore gay DVDs to the exclusive content section, you have quite a bit to see here. I couldn't quite count it up myself, but expect several hundred video clips at minimum, which is a great start.

  All exclusive content.

Unless you're familiar with the company, it's a little tough to tell from an average user's standpoint, but all of their content is exclusive here that they shoot themselves. The section labeled as exclusive is actually their web-exclusive content that's never been seen elsewhere. Their other collections are available on DVD, but it's still all their own content at least.

Other Good Stuff:

  • The design of the site is pretty nice, with some clean looks and nice colors.

The Cons

  Can't download the videos.

Anywhere you go here, the videos are all streaming-only unfortunately. There are no downloads available, and there's only the Flash streaming option. It comes in two sizes, but the larger one isn't "HD" as labeled of course. If they can't do downloads, I'd at least like a few different streaming options (WMV, Flash, several quality levels for each).

  Navigation is a little confusing/cluttered.

You're kinda browsing around through their dates and categories, and many of them aren't even in order (check out the exclusive section with the dates and all). From there, all the clips from a DVD are listed on a single page, and they play right there in that page, which makes things cluttered. Most DVD sites have the actual video scene playing on its own page, which cleans things up a bit.

  Quality could be a little better.

The quality of the videos here was a little subpar in my opinion, with more compression than we're used to seeing. It may be partly due to the streaming option, but we've seen some great streaming as well. The pictures are extremely tiny at 600x520, which isn't good either. Plus, most of the material seems to be older, which means part of the problem is the nature of the beast here.

Minor Negatives:

  • The video layout was annoying enough for me to get its own response here. I really don't like the videos playing right on the same page as the rest of the gallery listing. It's made even worse since they try to drag the video to the top of the page when it starts playing, so you have to scroll way up to see it again. It's weird.
  • A lot of the content is older here, which affects the quality (see above), plus just the style of site it is. Don't come here expecting 2010 bodybuilders in action, and you should be okay.
  • There are no zip files available here for the photo galleries, which may be annoying for some.
  • There are no update dates on the content inside the member's area. Their tour offers up the latest three update dates in each section, but that's pretty minimal in terms of information.

Bottom Line

A pretty different collection, but it's actually not too bad by the numbers.

Athletic Model Guild offers up a pretty different collection, and it didn't quite work for me overall. However, looking at the numbers and stuff, they are actually doing well. They have quite a bit to see, update pretty often, offer up a nice-looking site, have all-exclusive content, and don't charge too much. I'd love to see a few more navigation options, and I'd love to change the video setup somehow (if they want to stick with streaming, at least put the videos on their own page). Look around the tour at the older content (and the wide variety) and see if it's up your alley. I'm more used to today's high-tech sites with fresh content, so it didn't quite work for me. However, if you like what you see, I think they give you a decent amount for your money here. Fans of AMG already know what they're in for, and should have a great time here.

Site Details

About the Content: 
Unique, exclusive scenes featuring well-built men posing, wrestling, and more. They also feature their gay DVD collection here as well.

Download Managers: 
No downloads available.

Download Speed: 
No downloads available.

Exclusive Info: 
Advertised: No info found.
My Opinion: It turns out everything is exclusive here, even the videos not listed in the "exclusives" section. The only caveat is if you've purchased or seen an AMG DVD in the past somewhere else.

File Sizes (HQ): 
JPG = ~40KB
(average size, HQ)

HD Video: 
No HD quality videos.

Live Cams: 
No free live cam shows.

Logging In: 
Only user/pw required.
Videos don't require pw.

Model Appearance: 
Mostly white models.
Generally amateur-looking.
Body types from usually muscular.

Model Info: 
900+ models total.
Ages 18-40.

Other Content: 
Pretty good blog.

Other Details: 
Some condoms seen at times.
No music in most videos.
A few banners ads.

Pic Details: 
Older photography.
Little to no airbrushing.

Pic Dimensions (HQ): 
Most = 600 x 520
Most images in portrait.
Sizes vary a little.

Streaming Player: 
Medium flash player.
Must download to jump around.
2-5 second buffer.
Smooth playback.
Okay quality.

Updates in Last 7 Days: 
2 image galleries.
1 full video episode.
(on par with previous updates)
(site owner verifies actually five updates per week, though a few aren't dated)

Re-Review Status
No Plans Yet

Nominate this site (see the nominate box) if you'd like to see a new review.
We do not have an active member pass required to do a new review.

User Feedback Most recent user reviews and comments, up to 10 each displayed.


Register to submit your reviews and comments.
Recent Reviews (0)

None so far.

Submit : Add ReviewAdd Comment

Comments (0)

None so far.

View All: User Reviews & Comments (0)

Outside Reviews
Scores from other online adult review sites.

No Outside Reviews Found.

Outside Review dates and scores are submitted to us directly by the approved review site periodically. We have limited control over the scores displayed.

Contact Us - FAQ's - Glossary - Announcements - Terms Of Service - Privacy Policy - DMCA - 2257 - Porn Reviews - Webmasters


  Protecting Minors
We are strong supporters of RTA and ICRA, two of the most recognized self labeling organizations. Our site is properly labeled to assist in the protection of minors accessing inappopriate content. For information about filtering tools, check this site.

To report child pornography, go directly to ASACP! We're proud to be a corporate sponsor.
Have concerns or questions about porn addiction? We recommend this helpful resource.

All Rights Reserved © 2003-2018 Design and Reviews are copyrighted.

Last Update: 12-20-10